Theme
Critical raw materials in the Circular Economy Monitor
The importance of critical raw materials to the Flemish economy is growing rapidly. The energy transition, the electrification of mobility and continued digitalisation are driving up demand for, among others, lithium, cobalt, nickel, copper, graphite and rare earth elements. At the same time, Flanders is heavily dependent on international value chains for many of these materials. This makes their availability not only an economic and industrial issue, but also an important point of attention for circular economy policy.
The Circular Economy Monitor already offers a few tentative indications of Flanders’ position on critical raw materials: several parts of the monitor already contain data that are relevant to this theme. For example, we map the import dependency of total Flemish material use, and we present a number of figures on, for instance, electrical and electronic equipment and vehicles, and on water. For the time being, this information is still spread across various indicators, product groups and societal needs. The next step is to connect these building blocks and to develop and expand them further, in combination with policy-oriented research yet to be set up within a future Policy Research Centre for the Circular Economy (for example, scenario analysis and impact assessment of policy measures, as well as an in-depth analysis of Flemish knowledge needs in this context), in order to develop, in a targeted way, information that can be used for concrete policy choices and future scenarios.
What the monitor already shows
Although critical raw materials do not yet form a separate chapter within the Circular Economy Monitor, they are already clearly present in several sections. After all, the monitor not only maps overall material use, but also looks at the products and systems through which needs such as housing, mobility, food and consumption are met. Product-oriented information of this kind can form the basis for a more systematic analysis of critical raw materials.
1. Electrical and electronic equipment
A first important component concerns electrical and electronic equipment. Thanks to data from Recupel, there is a solid basis for mapping the quantities of equipment that are placed on the market, present in households, collected and processed. Particularly relevant are the results of the ownership surveys. These show how many televisions, laptops, mobile phones, household appliances and other devices Flemish households own, including devices that are no longer in use but are still kept at home. Together, these products represent a considerable stock of metals and other valuable materials.
The ownership figures do not yet tell us directly how much lithium, cobalt, copper, gold, palladium or rare earth elements are present in Flanders. They do, however, provide a relevant basis for estimating such quantities in a subsequent step. By linking the number of devices present to data on the average material composition per product type, a picture can emerge of the stock of critical raw materials that is currently in use or that may become available in the longer term.
The monitor also shows that small electrical appliances still regularly end up in household residual waste. For the critical raw materials they contain, this generally means an almost complete loss of material value. These are often relatively small products, but the concentration of valuable metals can be considerable. Better collection is therefore important not only for safe waste management policy, but also for raw materials policy.
The figures shown on reuse and repair also deserve attention in this context. Every appliance that is used for longer reduces, during that period, the need to produce and import a replacement device. Extending product lifetimes therefore limits both waste generation and the demand for new critical raw materials.
Possible extensions include the inclusion of professional equipment, the refinement of data on the material composition of product groups, and the mapping of the specific materials that are actually recovered during processing.
2. Electrification of mobility
A second component is the electrification of mobility: the monitor shows the strong growth in the number of electric vehicles in the Flemish vehicle fleet. The rising average mass of new passenger cars is also shown. Mass is not in itself an indicator of critical raw materials, but its evolution does give an important signal: not only that technological greening does not automatically lead to lower material use, but also that the material base of the mobility system is already undergoing rapid change: the batteries and electric motors of electric vehicles contain, among other things, lithium and neodymium.
The monitor also looks further, at how mobility needs are met. Electric bicycles and speed pedelecs also contain critical raw materials, but have a considerably smaller material requirement than electric passenger cars. To the extent that these replace car ownership, they can contribute to a substantial reduction in total material demand. Strategies such as car sharing, carpooling, higher occupancy rates and longer vehicle lifespans are also relevant. The monitor therefore tracks, among other things, the size and composition of the vehicle fleet, shared mobility, the average age of vehicles and the number of kilometres driven by vehicles at the point of scrapping. For electric vehicles, additional information will be needed on the destination of the battery.
A logical next step is to estimate the quantities of critical raw materials present in the Flemish vehicle fleet. For this, vehicle data can be linked to assumptions about battery capacity, battery chemistry, motor technology and average material content. Because technologies are changing quickly, these assumptions will need to be differentiated by year of manufacture and vehicle type.
3. Water and phosphorus
The monitor also takes a broader view of critical raw materials. Water use, for example, is mapped both at macro level and within specific applications, including food production. Water is a strategically vulnerable resource for Flanders. Given the high population density, intensive economic activity, limited natural water reserves and the growing effects of drought, it makes sense to include water explicitly in a Flemish analysis of raw material dependency and circularity. The monitor also contains information on phosphate flows in the food system. Phosphorus is essential for agriculture and food production and cannot be replaced by another nutrient. At the same time, primary production is geographically concentrated. The situation in Flanders is a particular one because, on the one hand, large quantities of phosphorus are imported via animal feed, fertilisers and food products, while on the other hand phosphorus losses put pressure on soil and water. These examples broaden the focus from the availability of critical raw materials to environmental pressure.
4. Solar panels, wind turbines and energy storage
In the longer term, we aim to carry out a material-focused analysis of the energy transition. Flanders has by now built up a considerable stock of solar panels and other energy installations. A large proportion of these products are still in use. To map the expected waste streams and their valorisation potential, an analysis of the stock present is important. Such an analysis can also help to develop sufficient capacity in good time for collection, reuse, repair, dismantling and high-quality recycling. Collaboration with professional players in the value chains concerned, such as producers, installers, collectors, processors and recycling companies, is essential here.
Why a complete Flemish overview is not yet possible today
The main limitation currently lies in the level of detail of the available versus the required material flow data. The economy-wide statistics distinguish between biomass, metals, non-metallic minerals and fossil raw materials; the underlying trade statistics do not readily allow individual critical raw materials to be distinguished. A full monitoring framework will therefore have to combine various data and methods in order to enable an integrated overview of Flanders’ raw materials position, in collaboration with the stakeholders in the value chains concerned. After an analysis of the highest-priority raw materials, products and value chains in the context of critical raw materials, based on the evolving policy context in Flanders, one could consider developing stock models, analysing the effectiveness of CE policy measures and carrying out scenario analysis, for example to show how different policy options affect import requirements, domestic stock, future waste streams and the potential for recovery.